A Vincent van Gogh painting valued at an estimated 180 million dollars is at the centre of a dispute involving the descendants of its former Jewish owner. The painting, titled Châtaigniers en fleurs, or Chestnut Trees in Blossom, is scheduled to be sold by Sotheby’s in New York. The artwork was created in 1890, during the final period of van Gogh’s life, and could set a new auction record for the Dutch painter. However, the descendants of German publisher Samuel Fischer argue that the painting may have been sold under pressure during the Nazi era.
The Fischer family acquired the work in Paris in 1909. Their descendants say the circumstances surrounding its sale in 1936 need further examination because the family was experiencing financial difficulties under Nazi persecution. They want Sotheby’s to establish that the transaction was voluntary and that the price reflected the painting’s actual market value. Their lawyer has asked the auction house to provide evidence that the family would have sold the work regardless of the political and economic conditions of the time.
Sotheby’s says it has carried out extensive research into the painting’s ownership history. According to the auction house, the artwork was consigned to a gallery owner in Amsterdam between 1932 and 1933 and sold in June 1936 for 68,000 Swiss francs. The company says its research has not established that the sale was forced or that the painting was sold below its market value. Sotheby’s has also stated that it remains in contact with the Fischer heirs and wants to reach a solution acceptable to both sides.
The dispute highlights the wider issue of artworks that changed hands during periods of persecution, war and political instability. Museums, galleries and auction houses have faced growing pressure to investigate the history of valuable objects before selling or displaying them. Provenance research can involve old financial records, family documents, correspondence and historical evidence. The outcome of this case could attract attention well beyond the art market because it raises questions about ownership, historical responsibility and the treatment of cultural property connected to the Nazi period.

